First-Time Broadway Goers: Choosing the Best Broadway Show in 2024

Broadway, Entertainment

There’s Plenty of Great Upcoming Broadway Shows for Groups 

Planning your first journey to the heart of New York’s dazzling theatre district in 2024? As you stand at the cusp of choosing from a wide array of theatrical works, don’t let the abundance of options overwhelm you—we’re here to offer some advice to illuminate your path to an extraordinary Broadway experience. This blog is your ultimate roadmap to a production that resonates with your tastes and leads to a night etched in memory. Dive into the wide selection of narratives and styles that Broadway has to offer, and let us craft a custom-tailored cultural adventure just for you.

Best Broadway Shows for a First-Time Visitor:

For first-timers, entering the world of Broadway can be an overwhelming yet exciting experience. Every year, millions of tourists and locals alike are drawn to the enchanting atmosphere that Broadway offers, and most of them start with classic shows that have won the hearts of viewers globally. Going for something known and loved is a great way to get acquainted with just what musical theatre is and set yourself up for a great evening of live performance. 

  • One of the iconic Broadway shows perfect for first-timers is The Lion King. A musical rendition of Disney’s classic animated film, the show transports audiences into the vibrant world of Simba, the rightful lion king, pitted against his cunning uncle, Scar. Performed at the Minskoff Theatre in New York, this visually stunning musical engages the audience with impressive costumes and puppetry, soul-stirring music, and a compelling story. The Broadway production of The Lion King runs for approximately two and a half hours, including one intermission, and is recommended for ages six and up, making it a fantastic introductory experience to Broadway for the whole family. 


Alladin is one of the best Broadway shows for groups in NY

Alladin is one of the best Broadway shows for groups in NY

  • Aladdin is a sure show-stopper and a delightful introduction to the world of Broadway for first-timers. Housed in the historic New Amsterdam Theatre, the show weaves a tale of magic, romance, and adventure that leaves audiences spellbound. Bringing one of Disney’s most beloved tales to life, Aladdin chronicles the story of a witty street urchin who stumbles across a magic lamp amongst desert sands, thus commencing an exhilarating journey that upends his world. The production features grand sets and costumes, transforming the stage into a visual masterpiece. Its musical score is a highlight, boasting memorable numbers like “Friend Like Me,” “A Whole New World,” and “Prince Ali..” With a runtime of about two and a half hours, including an intermission, the show strikes the perfect balance between entertainment and engagement, ensuring an enchanting experience from start to finish. 


Miguel Cervantes and company in HAMILTON on Broadway - photo credit Joan Marcus

Miguel Cervantes and company in HAMILTON on Broadway – photo credit Joan Marcus

  • If you’re a fan of innovative storytelling, riveting performances, and groundbreaking music, Hamilton on Broadway is an absolute must-see. This genre-defining masterpiece is a masterful retelling of the life of forgotten American Founding Father, Alexander Hamilton. Its thrilling narrative is brought to life through the expert blend of traditional theatre music with pop, hip-hop, and R&B, making it a unique production that has unquestionably left its mark on Broadway and the world. The lyrical libretto, stirring performances, and resonant themes of revolution, ambition, and legacy make Hamilton more than just a musical but a cultural phenomenon that continues to captivate audiences around the globe.


Harry Potter and the Cursed Child on Broadway in New York Photo By Matthew Murphy

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child on Broadway in New York Photo By Matthew Murphy

  • Our last recommendation, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child takes theatre-goers on a thrilling return trip to the Wizarding World, picking up where the beloved series left off. The narrative extends the enchanting world of Hogwarts and magic, spinning a tale of friendship, courage, and facing one’s inner darkness. Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is a unique experience that meticulously translates the charm and wonder of the novel onto the stage with its plot, surprise twists, visually stunning special effects, and remarkable performances. The show engulfs its audience in a realm of magic, making it a must-see, especially for Harry Potter fans. In essence, it reminds us that Harry Potter was never just a phase but a feeling, a home, and a memory that lives on stage now!


What’s New on Broadway in 2024?

As dawn breaks over the New York skyline in 2024, the heart of the city, Broadway, still beats strong, pulsating with thrilling performances, resonating stories, and awe-inspiring talent that ignites the night. There is no energy quite like the one radiating from the theater district; its vibrant hum is tugging at the spirits of theater enthusiasts and first-timers alike, inviting them to experience one-of-a-kind Broadway performances.

Celebrated for its world-class productions, Broadway’s fresh line-up of 2024 shows is set to inspire conversation and leave lasting impressions on every visitor. So, come, venture into New York’s glowing heart, and let the magnificence of 2024’s Broadway shows lead you on an unforgettable expedition. 

WATER FOR ELEPHANTS - Original Alliance Cast - Photo by Matthew Murphy

WATER FOR ELEPHANTS – Original Alliance Cast – Photo by Matthew Murphy

Water for Elephants on Broadway

Coming to Broadway, Water for Elephants is an astounding narrative reborn as a unique spectacle new musical directed by Tony Award® nominee Jessica Stone. Based on the bestselling novel by Sara Gruen, the musical thrives under the craftsmanship of three-time Tony® nominee Rick Elice, translating words into actions that beautifully depict a poignant tale.

Packed with emotion and thrilling anticipation, it slickly navigates the landscape of human resilience when a young lad, after suffering the brunt of life, leaps into a moving train, marking the inception of nothing less than a relentless epic adventure. This leap draws him closer to the motley crew of a traveling circus, propelling him into a whirlwind of affection that he had only dreamt of.

The narrative elegantly unfolds through the lenses of the protagonist’s older self, where every thrilling exploit amplifies his wisdom about life and its unexpected gifts. The extraordinary score by PigPen Theatre Co. elevates the emotional depth of this intricate tale, rendering an authentic and deeply moving musical experience. Inviting audiences into an immersive journey, Water for Elephants is a bold testament to embracing the unknown and embarking upon life’s ride, irrespective of age.

Suffs Takes Broadway by Storm

A truly powerful musical is set to grace the stage in 2024—Suffs. This groundbreaking production, set to open at the Music Box Theatre, tells the story of the suffragists’ fight for the right to vote in the years leading up to the 19th Amendment. With book, music, and lyrics by the talented Shaina Taub, Suffs promises an exploration of victories and failures, a testament to the forgotten women who battled divides and oppression.

As the curtains rise on April 18, 2024, the audience will be transported to a time of selfless activism and resilience. The musical, having had an extended world premiere run Off-Broadway, has undergone substantial revisions, ensuring a fresh and compelling experience for Broadway-goers. Director Leigh Silverman leads a largely new creative team, bringing renewed energy to Taub’s remarkable musical.

Co-producers Hillary Clinton and Malala Yousafzai add a layer of significance to the piece, standing as symbols of dedication and courage in the fight for equality. Their involvement reflects a shared commitment to shining a spotlight on the unsung heroes of the American women’s suffrage movement. As the production unfolds, audiences can expect a soul-stirring narrative that resonates not only with the past struggles for democracy but also with the ongoing battles for equality around the globe.

Lempicka Announcement with Emilio Madrid

Lempicka Announcement with Emilio Madrid

Lempicka is a Great Broadway Musical for Groups

Prepare to be swept away by a musical portrait of one of the world’s greatest artists. After receiving acclaim at the Williamstown Theatre Festival and the La Jolla Playhouse, this New York Times Critic’s Pick is set to rock Broadway in 2024. Directed by the Tony AwardⓇ-winning force behind Hadestown, the production stars the phenomenal Eden Espinosa and promises a journey through decades of political and personal turmoil.

The narrative unfolds as aristocrat Polish-Jewish-born Tamara de Lempicka, fleeing the Russian revolution, forges a new life filled with passion, ambition, and the pursuit of art. The score, a thrilling blend of pop-infused melodies by Matt Gould and Carson Kreitzer, amplifies the emotional resonance of Tamara’s odyssey. As she encounters the free-spirited Rafaela, a prostitute on the fringes of Parisian society, the canvas of Lempicka becomes a rich blend of love, sacrifice, and the transformative power of art.

The production deals with the contradictions of a world in crisis, offering audiences a glimpse into the beauty and danger of an artist’s pursuit. Inspired by the life of Tamara de Lempicka, who ascended from penniless refugee to art world star during a tumultuous era, the show is not just a musical; it’s a celebration of the human spirit’s capacity for creativity and ability to thrive through adversity.

As the lights dim and the vibrant hues of Tamara’s art come to life on Broadway, prepare to be transported into a world where passion knows no bounds and the legacy of a visionary artist takes center stage.

The Outsiders on Broadway

Get ready for a seismic Broadway event as The Outsiders makes its triumphant arrival in spring 2024. This musical adaptation of the beloved novel and film, having premiered at the La Jolla Playhouse, promises a gripping narrative set against the backdrop of 1967 Tulsa, Oklahoma. Previews begin on March 16, with an official opening on April 11 at the Bernard B. Jacobs Theatre.

Produced by The Araca Group, American Zoetrope, and the illustrious Angelina Jolie making her Broadway producing debut, The Outsiders brings together a stellar team to breathe new life into S.E. Hinton’s iconic tale. With music and lyrics by Jamestown Revival and a book by Adam Rapp, the musical explores themes of survival, identity, and the quest for purpose in a world that may never fully accept its outsiders.

As the cast for Broadway is yet to be announced, anticipation builds for the revelation of the actors who will bring iconic characters Ponyboy Curtis, Johnny Cade, and their chosen family to life. Directed by Danya Taymor, with a creative team featuring scenic design by AMP and musical arrangements by Justin Levine, The Outsiders promises a visceral and evocative journey into the tumultuous world of the Greasers and the Socs. For those craving a potent blend of nostalgia and raw emotion, The Outsiders is a time-traveling experience that captures the essence of a pivotal moment in American history. 

Broadway Inbound is a great resource for Broadway Information and tickets. For more information about New York travel and other entertainment, be sure to Subscribe to Leisure Group Travel for FREE

Latest Traveling Tribes Podcast

Download Latest Issue

Recent from Entertainment

3 Myrtle Beach Venues with Fun, Flavor and Sophistication

3 Myrtle Beach Venues with Fun, Flavor and Sophistication

These Myrtle Beach venues are serving up unique palate-pleasers, live entertainment and memorable ambiances South Carolina is famed for sun-filled activities, succulent local wines and some of the freshest seafood options on the East Coast. With so many options, check...

The MJ Broadway Show is a Tribute to the ‘King of Pop’

The MJ Broadway Show is a Tribute to the ‘King of Pop’

Travel groups in NY looking for a show just need to experience the MJ Broadway show The indelible mark of the legendary ‘King of Pop’ Michael Jackson continues to reverberate across the globe. Recognized universally, Jackson's unique style and prodigious success have...

Subscribe for Free